©foodforum.org.uk 2000
All rights reserved


About this section  |  User Notes  | 
Company  |  Product  |  Design and development  |  Manufacture  |  Marketing  |  Issues and values  |  Making use  |  Resources  | 

Yeo Valley Organic

About the company

The name Yeo Valley began when an independently owned company was set up in 1974, from a dairy farm in Blagdon, near Bristol, to produce yogurts and desserts. In 1994, a few of the neighbouring farmers moved over to organic milk production and gained Soil Association approval. A co-operative called OMSCo (Organic Milk Suppliers Co-operative) was set up by the farmers. OMSCo is now the UK's leading organic milk marketing organisation. Its membership is now over 350 farmers across the UK, which is the majority of organic milk produced in this country. OMSCo represents approximately 60% of the total UK organic milk production.

Organic yogurt was first made at Yeo Valley's production plant in 1993, when these founder members of OMSCo were looking for a ready market for their milk. Although the level of consumer demand for organic dairy products was low at that time, Yeo Valley saw this as an opportunity to benefit from a local supply of organic raw material. In 1996, the company set up a second business called The Yeo Valley Organic Company Ltd, solely to produce organic products. The company has two organic production sites employing around 220 people - Cannington in Somerset (a yogurt dairy) and Heathfield in Devon (producing ice cream and frozen yogurt).

Whilst best known for its organic yogurt range, Yeo Valley Organic uses surplus cream, created as a by-product of the increased production of low fat yogurt, in its range of cream, créme fraiche and ice cream.

The group's headquarters provides centralised support for the whole company - technical, business, engineering, commercial, IT and financial expertise. Fairness and equitable trading with its suppliers and customers is part of Yeo Valley's ethos, as well as the promotion of organic farming methods and food consumption. The family is still family-owned and continues to run its own farm with around 450 dairy cows, plus organic sheep and beef.

back to top

About the product
Yeo Valley Organic thick wholemilk yogurt, either sold as a natural product (with no added sugar or fruit) or with apricot, raspberry, plum, blackcurrent or strawberry has now been joined by a range of fat-free natural and fruited products. The Yeo Valley Organic range aims to appeal to consumers who want to buy organic yogurt with only a small premium to standard, non-organic yogurt.

The packaging design used is innovative. The previous packaging for the yogurt pots was polyethelene-coated card, with a foil lid. This has been replaced by a more environmentally friendly uncoated, unbleached material produced from 98% recycled card. It has a vertical perforation allowing it to be torn off to reveal information for the consumer on the inside as well as the outside. The rigid outer card surrounds a thin, enclosed polypropylene pot. Together these materials form a composite package. As well as single 150g pots, the fruited yogurts are also sold in mixed packs of four 125g pots, offering a wider range of fruit flavours.

back to top

About the design and development process
Yogurt is a cultured milk, ie. it is produced by adding a specific bacterial culture to milk (in this case, S.Thermophilus, L.Actobacillus Acidophilus and B. Bifidum). This converts milk sugar (lactose) into lactic acid. Other chemical bi-products are formed in smaller amounts by this fermentation process. These include carbon dioxide, acetic acid, diacetyl and acetaldehyde which contribute to yogurt's characteristic taste and aroma.

Key features of manufactured yogurt are: flavour, aroma, appearance and texture. Many of the operations in the manufacture of yogurt are designed to help create or maintain a thick texture. These include:

  • standardisation of the whole milk, by ensuring it contains at least 3.3% fat and 12 - 18% Milk Solids Not Fat by adding skimmed milk (in the form of a concentrate produced by evaporating water from the milk once the cream has been skimmed from it)
  • homogenisation to increase the products viscosity
  • pasteurisation at 98 degrees C for 3 minutes to partially denature the milk proteins and aid coagulation
  • filtration to break up any pockets of whey that may have formed during fermentation
  • cooling is carried out slowly using a sophisticated ten-stage system, in a controlled manner, which protects the yogurt's thickness
  • taking care when moving, pumping or mixing the yogurt to use methods that protect and maintain viscosity

back to top

About the manufacture

 

 

Once made, the stirred yogurt is incubated in tanks and cooled before packaging into 150g or 450g pots. 125g pots are also packaged into fours for a fruited selection.

The whole manufacturing process takes approximately 22.5 hours. The starter culture is bought from a specialist culture manufacturer, having been freeze-dried and packaged in foil pouches. This direct vat inoculation (DVI) method minimises the risk of contamination and makes a separate culture room unnecessary.

The organic fruit is purchased from co-operatives abroad and processed by a local fruit producer, before being sent to the Yeo Valley organic site as a pre-prepared fruit mix or conserve.

Unit operations and their control

Five important unit operations in yogurt manufacture are outlined here:

  • obtaining the correct proportion of Milk Solids Not Fat (MSNF)
  • heat treatment
  • homogenisation
  • quality assurance
  • process control
milk silos (storage containers) process control panel milk homogeniser - two hydraulic piston pumps push milk through homogeniser valves


milk pasteuriser yogurt fermentation tanks drawing off the yogurt into a mobile tank

adding fruit

filling heads depositing yogurt into pots quality checking


loading pots into card trays overview of palletising room blast cooler



Milk Solids Not Fat (MSNF
)
In order to manufacture a yogurt with a consistently good texture, ie. firm and with little separation of liquid (sineresis), it is possible to use additives such as gelatin or gums. However, consumers often prefer yogurts with only milk and fruit-based ingredients. To achieve a firm, even textured product it is usual for manufacturers to increase the solids content of the original milk (solids predominantly consist of protein, lactose, vitamins and minerals). The solids levels of milk may be raised for yogurt making by adding concentrated milk, removing some water by evaporation, or by adding skimmed milk powder. Most yogurt contains 12-18% solids (referred to as Milk Solids Not Fat). This is the legal minimum according to the Code of Practice for the Composition and Labelling of Yogurt Regulation, 1983. In order to calculate the amount of skimmed milk concentrate needed to achieve the required MSNF level for yogurt, the original milk is tested for fat content and MSNF in the laboratory. The required addition rate of skimmed milk concentrate can then be calculated.

Wholemilk yogurt must legally have a minimum fat content of 3%. Milk coming into the factory is standardised before processing to give a specific fat and dry matter content.

Heat Treatment
Although milk for yogurt making must be pasteurised in order to eliminate any pathogens or micro-organisms that may destroy or compete with the starter culture, a higher than usual time and temperature combination is used for yogurt making. Temperatures of around 90-98 degrees C for between 3 and 5 mins are used to partially denature the whey proteins (mostly B lactglobulin which can then react more readily with the k-casein). This helps to produce a yogurt with a firmer coagulum and reduces the risk of whey separation by sineresis.

Heat treatment is usually achieved using heat exchangers such as a Plate Heat Exchanger (PHE) or Tubular Heat Exchanger (THE). These both transfer heat into milk efficiently by indirect methods (see diagrams). The design and size of the heat exchanger used will depend on the required flow rate and temperature, cleaning, viscosity, running times etc.

The pasteuriser will deaerate the milk as it heats it, which is important when using skimmed milk powder.

 

Simplified diagram of a THE

 

 

 

 

 

 

Simplified diagram of a PHE

Homogenisation
Homogenisation of milk increases the viscosity of the final product, improves its stability and prevents a cream layer forming in the top of the yogurt incubation tanks. Homogenisers use pressures of approximately 150 - 200 bar, at temperatures of approximately 55-70 degrees C and may be single or double phase. This operation works by passing milk through a very small space at high velocity, usually under pressure to create a shearing effect (see diagram).

Simplified diagram of a single phase homogeniser valve

As the milk flows through the narrow gap the large fat droplets are torn apart, velocity increases and pressure falls to a level where it boils and bubbles form. As it leaves the gap the velocity falls and pressure increases again causing the steam bubbles to implode against the impact ring (cavitation). This reduces the size of the fat globules, as does turbulence (swirling action in all directions, to encourage rapid heat transfer and to get a good mixing action). The warm milk fat globules form a new fat:protein surface structure creating stability, a whiter appearance, better mouthfeel and a full bodied flavour.

Quality assurance
The Quality Assurance department carries out many checks to ensure that the yogurt made is of a consistently high quality and meets the product specification. They also check that incoming ingredients are suitable and meet the raw materials specification. The incoming milk is checked for temperature, taste, fat content, antibiotics, solids not fat and resazurin ( a type of dye that breaks down in the presence of oxygen - used as a quick hygiene test).

During the incubation period the yogurt is regularly checked for total acidity (after 2, 4, 5, 6, 6.5, 7, 7.5 and 8 hours.) A sample is taken aseptically from the incubation tank and titrated against 0.1 Molar sodium hydroxide with phenolphthalein indicator. Microbiological samples are taken post-pasteurisation and post-incubation and tested for Enterobacteriacacea, yeasts and moulds.

The final product is organoleptically tested for taste and appearance. Its viscosity is assessed and further microbiological tests, called Accelerated Shelf-life tests, are carried out at 25 degrees C over 2, 3 and 4 days, mainly looking for yeasts and moulds. Samples of each batch of finished product are retained and assessed at the end of life.

Process control
Control is important throughout the manufacturing process. Computers are used to control processing centrally and locally. They are also used to communicate information using sensors, transmitters and controllers. Control systems must communicate with every component and transmitter, so that each valve, pump or agitator can be checked using input and output signals every 0.2 seconds. These are processed by a Logic unit. This system will make appropriate decisions using the information provided to ensure the required quality standards.

 

A CIP (cleaning in place) system is used which is a highly controlled program allowing for equipment to be cleaned thoroughly, with detergent solutions circulating through product lines, without disassembly.

 

 

 

 

back to top

About the marketing
In the 12 months up to December 2004, the Yeo Valley Organic brand was the fourth biggest yogurt brand in the UK (after Muller, Ski and Shape) and it accounted for 6% of all yogurts sold in the multiple retail shops (supermarket chains). The brand grew by almost 20% in value year on year. Most of these products produced at the Cannington site are sold under the Yeo Valley Organic brand with some sold under retailer own brand labels.

A new packaging type has been in use since May 2000 and a new design was launched in March 2003. The new label has a modern appeal with a striking, clean, fresh image of fruit, or a wild daisy for natural products, on a background that is cream coloured for wholemilk yogurts and a light blue colour for fat free products.

In 2001, Yeo Valley Organic won the Queen's Award for Enterprise in sustainable development for their role in the development of a sustainable UK organic dairy supply chain. This also recognises Yeo Valley's work to develop long term, sustainable supply partnerships with their organic fruit growers and processors, and more environmentally friendly packaging for products.

In May 2001 Yeo Valley Organic launched its first national advertising campaign. The magazine adverts feature cartoon cows and take a light-hearted approach to promoting the brand and products, whilst highlighting their tasted and quality benefits. More recent advertising campaigns have developed the taste and quality message whilst highlighting the difference of organic products with the strap line: "Yeo Valley Organic: In a world gone mad, it's sanely delicious."

The aim is to present simple messages about the benefits of organic products without 'preaching' or bombarding the consumer with too much information. To learn more you can go to the Yeo Valley web site, which won an award for "Best Business to Consumer Website" in 2001 and has since been regularly updated.

back to top

About issues and values
Consumers have many choices available to them when shopping for food and labelling plays a role in helping them to make informed decisions.

    In a MAFF (now DEFRA) survey, 38% of consumers asked said that:
  • logos (egs. healthy eating or vegetarian symbols) would encourage them to buy the product
  • 9% look for organic
  • 18% check the origin of the food

The range of organic produce available has increased dramatically over the last ten years, from fruit and vegetables, to milk and dairy products and convenience foods.

According to the Soil Association's annual Food and Farming Report, published in October 2004, sales of organic food and drink rose to £1,119m per annum. In the total UK food market, 1.2% of all food sales in 2004 were organic. In what is described as the 'organic defined market' (where an organic version of conventional products exists) this percentage rises to over 2%.

 

Organic milk production has been the most attractive prospect in a dairy farming sector beset with problems, because the premium has dropped by 25% compared to 5 years ago. This leaves many conventional dairy farms unable to operate profitably. In that time, organic dairy farmers have gone from not being able to sell their milk to not being able to meet demand, though in the last two years supply has temporarily overtaken demand.

Generally, the shortage of home-grown organic produce in the UK can make it up to three times more expensive than non-organic food. Supermarkets estimate that demand for organic foods is higher than supply, but as more ingredients and products become available, some economies of scale will allow some of the price premiums to reduce. The Soil Association says that about 40% of shoppers are put off buying organic because of the cost. Prices are likely to fall as more UK producers are set up. However, there will continue to be organic cost premiums, due to the higher costs of organic farming. Many suppliers and retailers believe that organic produce should be an option for everyone, not just be for people of a certain income or social class.

The Yeo Valley Organic Company aims to promote the sale of organic foods in general, having developed close links with suppliers. They have long term rolling contacts with the OMSCo farmers that guarantee prices. When they set up at the Cannington dairy, as part of a large established company, they were able to make cost effective use of its infrastructure and purchasing power to develop and launch new products. They aim for sustainability by addressing the need to continue the growth in supply of organic milk. Profits are ploughed back as investment, especially for new plant and automation.

 

back to top

Making use of the case study - things to think about and do
Using this case study for the following tasks will help to develop your understanding about:

  • food product development - how a company adapts to changing consumer needs
  • food chemistry - fermentation
  • manufacturing - food materials, manufacturing, unit operations, process control
  • values issues - issues re. consumer demand for organic produce and clear product labelling

  • Investigate how the manufacture of the following types of yogurts differs:

    stirred
    set natural yogurt
    long life yogurt
    bio yogurt

  • Find out the meaning of the various symbols used on the Yeo Valley Organic Yogurt label.

  • Conduct a survey of the range and availability of organic foods in your locality. What are your conclusions? Outline and justify your views about organic foods.

  • Carry out cost comparisons between a number of organic foods and their non-organic equivalents.

  • Look at the Yeo Valley magazine advert in the 'About the marketing' section of this case study. What marketing techniques do you think are being used and why? How effective are they? In what other ways could organic values be promoted?

  • Using the information in the 'About the manufacture' section of this case study, produce a table that summarises how the characteristic flavour, appearance, aroma and texture of yogurt are obtained.

  • Using information in the 'About issues and values' section of this case study, consider put forward your views about the cost of organic food. Why is it more expensive than non-organic? What are the benefits? Is it worth it?

  • Produce HACCP details for the yogurt manufacture shown in the 'About the manufacture' section of this case study.

  • Carry out the following manufacturing experiment. If possible, use a computer to measure and log times and temperatures.
    1. Take 1 litre of wholemilk and heat to approximately 95 degrees C.
    2. Cool to approximately 30-40 degrees C.Add 2% live yogurt and stir well.
    3. Cover and leave in a warm place or incubator overnight at 30-40 degrees C.
    4. Compare the final texture with a bought wholemilk natural yogurt.
    5. Check for sineresis, body, smoothness and mouthfeel.
    6. Now repeat the process with a second batch, but before heating to 95 degrees C, add skimmed milk powder so as to increase the solids to 18%.
    7. Assume that for average wholemilk: 3.9% fat, 3.2% protein, 4.6% lactose, 0.7% minerals and vitamins.
    8. Incubate and compare final texture with a similar commercial product. Also compare to the first batch of yogurt made.

      back to top


      Further useful resources
      'D&T Routes: Food' , RCA, Hodder & Stoughton, 1997, p61
      'Design & Make it: Food Technology', Stanley Thornes, 1997, p86-87, 103, 154-157
      'Food Technology' Unit, British Nutrition Foundation, 1998, MAFF
      'Food Technology', Collins Real World Technology series, Inglis, Plews & Chapman, p94, 120
      'Examining Food Technology', Anne Barnett, Heinemann, 1996, p41-42
      'The Science and Technology of Foods', RK Proudlove, Forbes, 1994, p118-122
      'HACCP' CD-ROM, Economatics - industrial case studies, including pasteurisation (of cheese)
      National Dairy Council, 5 - 7 John Princes St, London W1 OAP and www.milk.co.uk
      'The Food Magazine', Issue 49, April/June 2000

      www.yeo-organic.co.uk
      www.omsco.co.uk

      www.nutrition.org.uk
      www.armfield.co.uk - information on benchtop plate freezers and pasteurising equipment
      www.defra.gov.uk
      www.soilassociation.org
      www.foodcomm.org.uk

      www.stepin.org

      ©foodforum.org.uk 2005. All rights reserved

      back to top

  •